New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORESYS::ONLINE|2026-11-12 10:34:48 UTC
Log InRegister
BELLYSCORE
THEME

Best Supernatural Games

Every Supernatural game The Belly has scored, ranked from the highest verdict down. Browse games with a Supernatural setting or subject and see where each one landed.

Games with a Supernatural theme, ranked by Belly Score. Theme tags capture the subject matter and setting of a game — distinct from genre — so this list pulls together titles that share a Supernatural world or aesthetic regardless of how they play. See which Supernatural-themed games earned The Belly's top marks and which fell short.

Best Supernatural Games rankings

136 games
SAY MY NAME
6.8

SAY MY NAME

Horror · Survival

Roblox

SupernaturalPsychologicalDark / Grim
CreepyEerieSuspenseful+3
Comment
Old A Bizarre Day
6.8

Old A Bizarre Day

Action · Fighting · RPG

PC · Mobile · Console

SupernaturalFantasyModern
ChaoticCompetitiveNostalgic+2
Comment
Jokesaken
6.6
Community
8.4
2 ratings

Jokesaken

Horror · Survival

PC · Mobile · Console

ComedySatireSupernatural
ChaoticFunnyQuirky+3
Comment
NeverDead
6.5

NeverDead

Action · Shooter

PlayStation 3 · Xbox 360

SupernaturalMonstersComedy
ChaoticWeirdFrantic+1
Comment
D
6.4

D

Adventure · Horror

3DO · Sega Saturn · PlayStation · MS-DOS · Windows · Macintosh · Linux

SupernaturalGothicDetective / Mystery+1
CreepyEerieAtmospheric+2
Comment
Five Nights TD 2
5.7

Five Nights TD 2

Strategy

Roblox

MonstersSupernatural
StrategicTacticalCooperative+3
Comment
JUJUTSU KAISEN: CURSED CLASH
5.6

JUJUTSU KAISEN: CURSED CLASH

Action · Fighting

PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X/S · Nintendo Switch · PC

SupernaturalModernMartial Arts
IntenseFast-PacedCompetitive+2
Comment
Super Godzilla
5.4

Super Godzilla

Action · Strategy · Fighting

Super Nintendo Entertainment System

MonstersSci-FiSupernatural
WeirdChallengingStrategic+2
Comment
Lords of the Fallen
4.9

Lords of the Fallen

Action RPG

PC · PlayStation 5 · Xbox Series X/S

Dark FantasyGothicMonsters+1
DarkChallengingBrutal+3
Comment
ROBLOX: LAND OF THE SUN
4.6

ROBLOX: LAND OF THE SUN

Action · Survival

PC · Mobile · Xbox · PlayStation

FantasySupernaturalPsychological+1
AtmosphericEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
Werewolf: The Apocalypse – Earthblood
3.8

Werewolf: The Apocalypse – Earthblood

Action RPG

Microsoft Windows · PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X/S

Urban FantasySupernaturalDark / Grim+1
IntenseAdrenaline-FueledBrutal+2
Comment
Sol's RNG
3.7

Sol's RNG

Simulation · Idle / Incremental

PC · Mobile · Console

FantasySupernatural
AddictiveGrind-HeavySatisfying+2
Comment
Redfall
3.1

Redfall

Action · FPS · Shooter

PC · Xbox Series X/S

VampiresSupernaturalModern
AtmosphericCooperativeIntense+2
Comment
Sonic the Hedgehog
2.7

Sonic the Hedgehog

Platformer · Action-Adventure

Xbox 360 · PlayStation 3

FantasyModernSupernatural
ChaoticWeirdCinematic+1
Comment
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
1.7

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

Action · Platformer

Nintendo Entertainment System

GothicSupernaturalPsychological+1
WeirdSurrealUnpredictable+2
Comment
Greyhill Incident
1.6

Greyhill Incident

Adventure · Horror

PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Windows · Xbox One · Xbox Series X/S

Sci-FiAlienSupernatural
CreepyEerieSuspenseful+2
Comment

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy