New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORESYS::ONLINE|2026-11-12 12:48:00 UTC
Log InRegister
BELLYSCORE
THEME

Best Supernatural Games

Every Supernatural game The Belly has scored, ranked from the highest verdict down. Browse games with a Supernatural setting or subject and see where each one landed.

Games with a Supernatural theme, ranked by Belly Score. Theme tags capture the subject matter and setting of a game — distinct from genre — so this list pulls together titles that share a Supernatural world or aesthetic regardless of how they play. See which Supernatural-themed games earned The Belly's top marks and which fell short.

Best Supernatural Games rankings

136 games
PURSUITCORE
8.7

PURSUITCORE

Survival · Fighting

Roblox

SupernaturalFolkloreSurreal+1
ChaoticIntenseFast-Paced+3
Comment
Kingdom Hearts 3D: Dream Drop Distance
8.7

Kingdom Hearts 3D: Dream Drop Distance

Action RPG · Adventure

Nintendo 3DS

FantasySupernaturalDreamlike
AdventurousFast-PacedWhimsical+3
Comment
KinitoPET
8.7

KinitoPET

Horror · Simulation

PC

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousCreepyUnsettling+3
Comment
Dead by Daylight
8.6

Dead by Daylight

Action · Horror · Survival

Windows · PlayStation 4 · Xbox One · Nintendo Switch · PlayStation 5 · Xbox Series X|S

MonstersDark / GrimSupernatural
CreepyTenseIntense+3
Comment
Noel the Mortal Fate Complete Edition
8.6

Noel the Mortal Fate Complete Edition

Adventure · RPG · Visual Novel

PC · Nintendo Switch · PlayStation 4 · Xbox One

Dark FantasySupernaturalDark / Grim+1
AtmosphericDramaticCinematic+2
Comment
bridger: WESTERN
8.5

bridger: WESTERN

Action · RPG · Survival

PC · Mac · Android · iOS · Xbox · PlayStation

WesternSupernaturalNature / Wilderness+1
AdventurousWildCompetitive+3
Comment
Backrooms: Survival
8.4

Backrooms: Survival

Adventure · Horror · Survival

Roblox

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
CreepyEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
Darkest Hours
8.4

Darkest Hours

Survival · Horror

PC · Roblox

SupernaturalDark / Grim
CreepyEerieTense+2
Comment
DELTATRAVELER
8.4

DELTATRAVELER

RPG · Adventure

Windows · Linux · macOS

FantasySupernaturalComedy+1
AdventurousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+3
Comment
Peroxide
8.3

Peroxide

Action RPG · RPG

Roblox

SupernaturalMartial ArtsDark / Grim
Fast-PacedCompetitiveChallenging+3
Comment
Sincere Deceit
8.3

Sincere Deceit

RPG · Puzzle · Horror

Windows

Dark / GrimPsychologicalSurreal+1
DarkUnsettlingAtmospheric+2
Comment
Rain
8.2

Rain

Adventure · Puzzle

PlayStation 3

SupernaturalDreamlikePsychological
AtmosphericDreamlikeMelancholic+3
Comment
Slayers 2
8.1

Slayers 2

Action RPG · Action-Adventure

Roblox

FantasySupernaturalNinja / Samurai+1
AdventurousEpicIntense+3
Comment
VV: ULTIMATUM
8.1

VV: ULTIMATUM

Action RPG · Fighting

Roblox

FantasySupernaturalDark / Grim
IntenseChallengingStrategic+3
Comment
DREDGE
7.9

DREDGE

Adventure · RPG · Survival

PC · Mac · PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X/S · Nintendo Switch

MonstersSupernaturalUnderwater+1
AtmosphericCreepyEerie+3
Comment
WEST WOOD: REMAKE
7.9

WEST WOOD: REMAKE

Survival · Horror

Desktop · Phone · Tablet · Console

Nature / WildernessSupernaturalDark / Grim
AtmosphericTenseChallenging+3
Comment
The Ring: Terror's Realm
7.8

The Ring: Terror's Realm

Horror · Survival

Dreamcast

SupernaturalPsychologicalModern
CreepyEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
Fullmetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel
7.8

Fullmetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel

Action RPG · Action-Adventure

PlayStation 2

FantasySupernatural
AdventurousNostalgicSingle-Player
Comment
Morimens
7.7

Morimens

RPG · Strategy

PC · Android · iOS

Dark FantasySupernaturalMonsters+1
AtmosphericStrategicDark+3
Comment
Sakura Stand
7.6

Sakura Stand

Fighting · RPG · Simulation

PC · Mobile · Xbox One

SuperheroMartial ArtsSupernatural
ChaoticCompetitiveAddictive+2
Comment
CHAIN
7.6

CHAIN

Horror · Survival

PC · Mobile · Console

SupernaturalDark / GrimPsychological
CreepyEerieScary+2
Comment
Evil West
7.5

Evil West

Action · Adventure · Shooter

PC · PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X|S

WesternSupernaturalVampires+1
IntenseFast-PacedBrutal+3
Comment
The Hybrid Cafe ☕
7.2

The Hybrid Cafe ☕

Simulation · Survival · Adventure

PC · Mobile · Xbox · PlayStation · VR

WorkplaceSupernaturalDark / Grim+1
ChaoticAtmosphericCooperative+3
Comment
ROBLOX: STAND UPRIGHT: REBOOTED
7.2

ROBLOX: STAND UPRIGHT: REBOOTED

Action · RPG · Fighting

Roblox

FantasyMartial ArtsSupernatural
CompetitiveChallengingGrind-Heavy+3
Comment

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy