New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORESYS::ONLINE|2026-11-14 12:18:22 UTC
Log InRegister
BELLYSCORE
THEME

Best Supernatural Games

Every Supernatural game The Belly has scored, ranked from the highest verdict down. Browse games with a Supernatural setting or subject and see where each one landed.

Games with a Supernatural theme, ranked by Belly Score. Theme tags capture the subject matter and setting of a game — distinct from genre — so this list pulls together titles that share a Supernatural world or aesthetic regardless of how they play. See which Supernatural-themed games earned The Belly's top marks and which fell short.

Best Supernatural Games rankings

136 games
Silent Hill 4: The Room
8.9

Silent Hill 4: The Room

Survival · Action · Adventure

PlayStation 2 · Xbox · PC

SupernaturalPsychologicalDark / Grim
CreepyEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
The Broken Script
8.9

The Broken Script

Horror

PC (Minecraft: Java Edition)

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousCreepyEerie+3
Comment
Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep
8.9

Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep

Action RPG · RPG

PlayStation Portable · PlayStation 3 · PlayStation 4 · Windows · Xbox One

FantasyMythologySupernatural
EpicImmersiveCinematic+3
Comment
Vigil: The Longest Night
8.9

Vigil: The Longest Night

Action RPG · RPG · Platformer

PC · Nintendo Switch

Dark FantasyGothicMonsters+1
DarkEerieBrutal+3
Comment
Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth
8.9

Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth

RPG

Nintendo 3DS

Urban FantasySchool / AcademySupernatural+1
ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenStrategic+3
Comment
Fate/unlimited codes
8.9

Fate/unlimited codes

Fighting

Arcade · PlayStation 2 · PlayStation Portable

FantasyUrban FantasyMartial Arts+1
Fast-PacedCompetitiveChallenging+3
Comment
Corpse Party: Blood Covered
8.9
Community
9.7
1 rating

Corpse Party: Blood Covered

Adventure · Horror

Microsoft Windows

SupernaturalSchool / AcademyPsychological+1
CreepyEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
Project JoJo
8.9

Project JoJo

Fighting · RPG

PC · Mobile · Xbox

FantasySupernaturalMartial Arts+1
AdventurousCompetitiveChallenging+3
Comment
CAPTURED 2
8.9

CAPTURED 2

Action · Adventure · Horror · Puzzle · Survival

PC · Steam

SupernaturalContemporaryMonsters+4
ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenMysterious+27
2 Comments
Charlie Murder
8.9

Charlie Murder

Action · RPG · Adventure

Xbox 360 · Windows · Linux · macOS

Dark / GrimComedySupernatural
ChaoticFast-PacedFunny+3
Comment
SCP retroBreach
8.9

SCP retroBreach

Action · Survival

Roblox

Sci-FiSupernaturalMonsters+1
ChaoticTenseMulti-Player+2
Comment
Shin Megami Tensei
8.9

Shin Megami Tensei

RPG

Super Famicom · Super CD-ROM² · Mega-CD · PlayStation · Game Boy Advance · Wii · PlayStation Network · iOS · Android · Wii U · Nintendo Switch

Post-ApocalypticUrban FantasySupernatural+1
DarkUnsettlingChallenging+3
Comment
Shin Megami Tensei if...
8.9

Shin Megami Tensei if...

RPG

Super Famicom · PlayStation · i-Revo · iOS · Wii · Wii U · Nintendo Switch

School / AcademySupernaturalDark / Grim
DarkChallengingAtmospheric+2
Comment
EarthBound
8.8

EarthBound

RPG · Adventure · Strategy

Super Nintendo Entertainment System · Wii U · New Nintendo 3DS · Nintendo Switch · Game Boy Advance

ModernSupernaturalComedy+2
AdventurousQuirkyWeird+5
Comment
EarthBound Beginnings
8.8

EarthBound Beginnings

RPG · Adventure

Nintendo Entertainment System · Wii U · Nintendo Switch · Game Boy Advance

ModernSupernaturalAlien+1
QuirkyWhimsicalCharming+2
Comment
Dead as Disco
8.8

Dead as Disco

Action · Rhythm / Music · Fighting

Windows

CyberpunkSupernaturalComedy
Fast-PacedEnergeticSatisfying+2
Comment
Friday Night Funkin': Hypno's Lullaby
8.8

Friday Night Funkin': Hypno's Lullaby

Rhythm / Music · Horror

Windows · macOS · Linux · Web

FolkloreSupernaturalMonsters+1
CreepyEerieUnsettling+3
Comment
Midnight Horrors
8.8

Midnight Horrors

Survival · Horror

PC · Mobile · Xbox · PlayStation

MonstersComedySatire+1
ChaoticUnpredictableCooperative+3
Comment
One More Night
8.8

One More Night

Survival · Strategy · Action

PC

SupernaturalPsychological
ChaoticIntenseMulti-Player+2
Comment
PWNed BY 14:00
8.8

PWNed BY 14:00

Horror · Survival

Roblox

SupernaturalMonstersPsychological+1
CreepyEerieChaotic+2
Comment
Kyuuyaku Megami Tensei
8.8

Kyuuyaku Megami Tensei

RPG · Adventure

Super Famicom · Wii

FantasySupernaturalMonsters+1
AtmosphericChallengingDark+2
Comment
KinitoPET
8.7

KinitoPET

Horror · Simulation

PC

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousCreepyUnsettling+3
Comment
PURSUITCORE
8.7

PURSUITCORE

Survival · Fighting

Roblox

SupernaturalFolkloreSurreal+1
ChaoticIntenseFast-Paced+3
Comment
Pillar Chase 2
8.7

Pillar Chase 2

Horror · Survival

PC · Mobile · Console

SupernaturalMonstersPsychological
IntenseFast-PacedChaotic+3
Comment

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy